Home / Templates / Bid/No-Bid Matrix

Free Template · Excel

Free Bid/No-Bid Decision Matrix For Government Contracts

Decide which federal opportunities deserve your time with evidence, not gut feel. Run six pass/fail gates, score eight weighted criteria and record a clear decision, with conditions and deadlines, before you spend a dollar on the proposal.

  • Six pass/fail gates that stop a bad bid before scoring starts
  • Eight criteria, each described at scores of 1, 3 and 5, with an evidence column
  • Weights you set for each opportunity, with a check that they total 100%
  • Your own cut-offs and four outcomes: advance, advance with conditions, reassess or do not pursue
Excel (.xlsx)Opens in Google SheetsRe-score at every gateFree

By Hijab Zainab, Research & Proposal Strategy Lead · Updated November 17, 2026

Free Download

Get The Bid/No-Bid Decision Matrix

Enter your name and work email. Your download starts right away.

← Back

Thank you for your response. ✨

Thank you! Your template is downloading.

By downloading, you agree to our Privacy Policy. We may email you about new templates and guides. You can unsubscribe at any time.

The Basics

What Is A Bid/No-Bid Decision Matrix?

A bid/no-bid decision matrix is a scoring sheet that helps you decide whether to pursue a government opportunity. You check the must-haves first, then score how well positioned you are on weighted criteria, and record the decision and the evidence behind it so the next review can follow your reasoning.

This template turns that into four steps on one tab: gates, scores, cut-offs and a decision. It suggests an outcome only once your team has set its own cut-offs.

For the full process, read our guide: How To Make A Bid/No-Bid Decision On A Government RFP.

The Download

What's Inside The Matrix

One Excel workbook. The Scorecard tab walks you through four steps, top to bottom, and a filled Example tab shows a finished decision.

1

Gates

You: Mark six must-haves Pass, Fail or Unknown, with evidence, a fix-by date and an owner.

The sheet: Shows Pass, Fail or Incomplete. Any Fail stops the scoring.

2

Score

You: Adjust the weights to this opportunity, then score each criterion from 1 to 5 with evidence.

The sheet: Calculates the weighted score and flags weights that don't total 100%.

3

Cut-offs

You: Set your own thresholds for each outcome, ideally before you score.

The sheet: Checks they run from high to low.

4

Decision

You: Make the final call and write conditions, deadlines and walk-away triggers.

The sheet: Suggests an outcome once gates, scores, weights and cut-offs are complete.

Bid/no-bid decision matrix in Excel with pass/fail gates, eight weighted scoring criteria and an evidence column
The Scorecard tab: opportunity details, the six gates and the start of the weighted scoring.

Step 1

Six Gates Before Any Scoring

Gates are yes-or-no questions. If you can't meet one, there is no point scoring the rest.

Set-asideYour size standard and any required certification
VehicleAccess to the contract vehicle, or a realistic teaming path
CredentialsRequired licenses, certifications and clearances
Key staffAvailable, or obtainable by contract start
PriceCovers your costs and a margin you can live with
CapacityTime and people to write a compliant proposal

Any Failmeans do not pursue, unless you can fix it by a named date. A high score can't make up for a failed gate.

Step 2

The Eight Scoring Criteria

Each criterion is described at scores of 1, 3 and 5 in the sheet. Here is what a 5 looks like, with the default weight.

Eligibility12.5%Scores 5 when: You are fully eligible to prime under the expected set-aside and vehicle
Customer Knowledge12.5%Scores 5 when: You have named contacts, know their priorities and spoke with the customer recently
Competitive Position12.5%Scores 5 when: You have clear discriminators and the incumbent is weak, leaving or absent
Past Performance12.5%Scores 5 when: You have recent, comparable federal work with good ratings
Solution And Staffing12.5%Scores 5 when: Your approach is proven and key personnel are committed with resumes
Price Competitiveness12.5%Scores 5 when: You understand the price to win and can win at an acceptable margin
Proposal Effort12.5%Scores 5 when: Your team, reviewers and time are available and the schedule fits
Strategic Value12.5%Scores 5 when: It is core to your strategy and opens an agency or vehicle
How Scoring Works
  • Score each criterion 1, 3 or 5, using the descriptions in the sheet
  • Write the evidence. A claim with no evidence scores 1
  • Weights start equal at 12.5% and must total 100%
  • Change them to fit what this solicitation rewards
Weights depend on each opportunity's requirements. See the signals below.

How To Use The Bid/No-Bid Matrix

Score Three Times: At Pursuit, Before The Proposal Starts And After The Final RFP.

Details and gates

Add the opportunity, agency, set-aside, vehicle, value and due date, then run the six gates with evidence.

Cut-offs and weights

Agree your cut-offs before scoring so numbers aren't bent to fit. Then adjust the weights and note why.

Score with evidence

Use the 1, 3 and 5 descriptions. Write what each score rests on, and score gaps low.

Decide and re-score

Make the call, record conditions and walk-away triggers, and score again at the next gate.

Ready to score your next opportunity?

Get The Free Matrix

Know What Matters

Why The Weights Should Change For Every Opportunity

No two opportunities should be scored the same way. Set the weights from what the solicitation rewards and what your business needs. If you see one of these signals, give more weight to the criterion shown.

Section M rates past performance as a leading factor

Past Performance

Award goes to the lowest price that is technically acceptable

Price Competitiveness

The technical approach is the most important factor

Solution And Staffing

A strong incumbent is likely to bid again

Competitive Position and Customer Knowledge

Your team is already stretched on other bids

Proposal Effort

It opens a new agency or contract vehicle for you

Strategic Value

Step 4

The Four Outcomes

Advance

Pursue it and move to the next gate or start the proposal.

Advance With Conditions

Pursue it only if named conditions are met by named dates, such as confirming a teaming partner.

Reassess

Not enough evidence yet. Close the gaps and score again before spending more.

Do Not Pursue

Walk away and put the effort into a better-fit opportunity.

Why There Are No Built-In Cut-Offs

There is no standard passing score for a bid decision. What counts as "good enough" depends on your win rate, your pipeline and how much a proposal costs you, so the matrix asks your team to set its own cut-offs and won't suggest an outcome until you do. Use the same cut-offs across opportunities and adjust them as you see which bids you win.

Tips And Tricks

Make Bid Decisions You Can Defend

Do This

  • Score on evidence, not hope. "The customer likes us" scores 1 unless you can name who said what, and when.
  • Treat missing information as a risk. Score it low and make finding it a condition.
  • Keep gates and scores separate. A high score can't make up for a gate you fail.
  • Decide as a group. Have someone who isn't championing the bid score it too, then compare.
  • Write walk-away triggers. Decide now what in the final RFP would make you stop.

Avoid This

  • Bidding on everything that matches your NAICS code
  • Deciding after the proposal has already started
  • Using the same weights for every opportunity
  • Treating the score as a probability of winning
  • Changing the cut-offs to fit a bid you already want
  • Never scoring again once the final RFP is out

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a good bid/no-bid score?

There is no universal number. Set your own cut-offs based on your win rate, pipeline and proposal costs, use them consistently, and adjust them as you learn which bids you win.

When should you make a bid/no-bid decision?

More than once. Score early when you first decide to pursue, again before the proposal starts, and again after the final RFP is released to confirm nothing has changed.

What criteria should a bid/no-bid decision include?

Start with must-haves such as eligibility, vehicle access, staffing and price. Then score positioning: customer knowledge, competitive position, past performance, solution and staffing, price competitiveness, proposal effort and strategic value.

Is the score my chance of winning?

No. It measures how well positioned you are, based on the evidence you have. Use it to compare opportunities and make a documented decision, not as a win probability.

Can I change the criteria?

Yes. You can rename criteria, change the score descriptions or set a weight to zero. Keep the weights totalling 100% so the score stays comparable.

Is the matrix really free?

Yes. Enter your name and work email and it downloads straight away. There is no cost and no obligation.

Want Bid Decisions Made For You?

Our Pipeline Monitoring includes written bid decisions: an opportunity snapshot, a scorecard on these eight criteria with the evidence for each, a recommendation and walk-away triggers.

Related Guides And Templates

Sources

Talk To Us About Your Next Bid

Book a free call at a time that suits you. We will come back with a clear view of where to start.