Home / Services / Proposal Review
Proposal Review For Small Businesses
Pre-Submission Proposal Review And Color Team Review Services For Government Contractors
Find what will cost you points before the evaluator does. We review your proposal against the RFP or RFQ the way an evaluator will score it, and rank the fixes by what they are worth.
RFPs And RFQsSections L and M, or the RFQ's instructions and basis for award
Pink, Red Or Goldone review at the stage you need
What your review covers
- Readiness summaryYour top 3 risks, up frontFirst page
- Compliance checkEvery Section L and M requirement, or every RFQ instruction, mapped to where you answer itLine by line
- Evaluator-style scoringStrengths, weaknesses and the likely rating for each factorBy factor
- Ranked fixesOrdered by the points at stakeBy points
- Submission checksPage limits, fonts, file names and instructionsBefore you submit
Where Proposals Lose Points
Why Strong Companies Lose Federal Bids For Avoidable Reasons
A Long RFP And A Short Deadline
Your team is already busy delivering, and the clock started the day the RFP dropped.
Strong Company, Average Scores
The proposal described what you do, not what the evaluators were told to score.
No Time For A Proper Review
Gaps and missed instructions only surface in the debrief. A pre-submission review catches them while there is still time to fix them.
Six Mistakes We Catch Most Often
- Missing or misreading a submission instruction
- Restating the statement of work instead of showing how the work gets done
- Claims without proof such as metrics, examples or named methods
- Talking about the company instead of the customer's outcomes
- Spreading pages evenly instead of following the weight of each evaluation factor
- Leaving reviews and formatting until the last day
The Sections That Decide Your Score
RFP Compliance Review Against Sections C, L, M And B
Most federal RFPs follow the Uniform Contract Format. Many task order and GSA schedule RFQs do not, and have no formal Sections L and M; for those, we build the check from the RFQ's instructions, basis for award, PWS and attachments. Either way, every requirement is checked against the proposal section that answers it, so nothing reaches the evaluator unanswered.
| RFP ref | Requirement | Answered in | Scored under | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Section L | Each submission instruction, such as page limits and fonts | Where your proposal answers it | The factor that scores it | Compliant |
| Section C | Each task in the statement of work | Where your proposal answers it | The factor that scores it | Weak |
| Section M | Each evaluation factor and subfactor | Where your proposal answers it | Its weight in the evaluation | Missing |
Section C: The Work
The statement of work, performance work statement or statement of objectives. Your technical approach must answer it in full.
Section L: The Instructions
What to submit, how to organize it, page limits and formatting. Miss one and the proposal can be ruled non-compliant.
Section M: The Scoring
The evaluation factors and their relative importance. It shows exactly where pages and effort earn the most points.
Section B And H/I: Price And Fine Print
Line items that shape your price volume, plus special requirements and clauses that carry obligations and costs.
Read M before L. Knowing how you will be scored first makes every decision easier, from the outline to the page budget.
How Our Proposal Review Services Work
Our Proposal Review Process
Receive the package
The full RFP with amendments and Q&A, plus the draft volume to review.
Map the requirements
Every Section L, M and C item checked against where the proposal answers it.
Score like an evaluator
Strengths, weaknesses and deficiencies by factor, with the likely rating.
Rank the fixes
Ordered by points at stake, so your team can choose what to fix first.
Check submission rules
Page limits, fonts, file names and submission instructions, line by line.
Debrief
A 30-minute walkthrough of the findings with your team.
One Review, Scored Like An Evaluator
Proposal Review Services For Small Businesses And In-House Teams
Per opportunity
Proposal Review
One volume of up to 20 pages at the pink, red or gold team stage, reviewed the way an evaluator will score it.
- Readiness summary and the top 3 risks
- Compliance check against Sections L and M, or the RFQ's instructions
- Evaluator-style scoring by factor, with the likely rating
- Fixes ranked by points at stake
- Formatting and submission checks, and a 30-minute debrief
- Longer volumes at $20 per extra page; at least 5 business days' notice
For in-house teams
The Same Review, Inside Your Process
Proposal teams use it for an outside senior reviewer at pink, red or gold team, especially in busy periods such as fiscal Q4.
- Works inside your process and templates
- One volume per review, booked bid by bid
- The same scoring and ranked fixes
- A reduced rate for Pipeline Monitoring clients
Common Questions
Proposal Review Services FAQs
What does a government proposal consultant do?
A proposal consultant helps turn a solicitation's requirements into a response evaluators can score highly: following the submission instructions exactly, organizing the response around the stated evaluation factors, and making technical, management and past performance content specific, credible and easy to evaluate. A non-compliant proposal can be eliminated however strong the solution, which is why compliance comes first. We focus on the review: scoring your draft the way an evaluator will and ranking the fixes.
Can you review our proposal on short notice?
Yes, when the timeline allows a proper review. Our standard turnaround needs at least 5 business days from receiving the full package. If you need it back sooner, a 50% rush fee applies, subject to availability. We confirm the review date in writing before work begins.
How long a volume does the review cover?
The $500 review covers one volume of up to 20 pages ($380 for Pipeline Monitoring clients). Longer volumes are $20 per extra page, and we confirm the page count and price in writing before we start.
Do you support in-house proposal teams?
Yes. Mid-size contractors use us as senior reviewers for color-team reviews or as extra capacity in busy periods such as fiscal Q4.
Do you write proposals?
No. We review them, so your team knows exactly what to fix.
What is a compliance matrix?
A compliance matrix is a table that maps every instruction and requirement in a solicitation, typically from Sections L, M and C, to the proposal section that answers it, the evaluation factor it supports and the person responsible. It is the main tool for making sure nothing is missed.
What are Section L and Section M in an RFP?
Section L contains the instructions to offerors: what to submit, how to organize it and formatting rules such as page limits. Section M describes how proposals will be evaluated, including the factors and their relative importance. Together they tell you what to submit and how it will be scored.
What is the difference between best value tradeoff and LPTA?
In a best value tradeoff, the government can pay more for a proposal with a stronger technical rating. In lowest price technically acceptable (LPTA), it awards to the lowest-priced proposal that meets the minimum technical standard. The revised FAR Part 15 also adds further source selection approaches, so check which one each solicitation uses.
What are color team reviews?
Color team reviews are structured reviews at set stages of proposal development. A Pink Team checks structure and strategy early, a Red Team scores a near-final draft like an evaluator, and a Gold Team gives final leadership approval before submission.
Can we win if we have little federal past performance?
Often, yes. Options include citing relevant commercial or subcontract work, teaming with a partner whose experience fills the gap, and highlighting key personnel experience where the solicitation allows it. The approach depends on how the RFP evaluates past performance.
Should we request a debriefing after losing?
It is usually worth it. A debriefing explains how your proposal was evaluated, including its strengths and weaknesses, and is one of the most useful inputs for your next bid. Request it promptly, because the deadlines for requesting one are short.
Talk To Us About Your Next Bid
Book a free call at a time that suits you. We will come back with a clear view of where to start.