Proposals · 8 Min Read · Includes Review Checklist
Color Team Reviews Explained: Pink, Red And Gold Team
What each proposal color team review checks, when to hold it, who should review, how to write useful comments and how small teams can run reviews without a big budget.
Quick Answer
Color team reviews are planned checkpoints where people outside the writing team review a proposal, each with one job. Pink team checks structure, compliance and win strategy on an early draft. Red team scores a nearly finished draft the way the government evaluators will, against Section M. Gold team confirms the fixes are in and the proposal is ready to submit. Other colors cover capture strategy (blue), competitors (black hat), pricing (green) and lessons learned (white hat).
What Is A Color Team Review?
A color team review is a structured internal review of a proposal at a set stage, named by color so everyone knows its purpose. The idea is simple: before the government judges your proposal, have someone who did not write it judge it first, using the same rules the evaluators will use.
The color names were popularized by Shipley Associates, whose public definitions give each review a single purpose (Shipley). Companies adapt the names and timing, so always agree what each review means before you schedule it.
The Color Teams At A Glance
| Review | Purpose | When | Main output |
|---|---|---|---|
| Blue team | Assess the capture strategy and win plan | Before the RFP, during capture | A go-forward strategy and win themes |
| Black hat | Predict what competitors will propose | Before or early in the proposal | Competitor profiles and how to counter them |
| Pink team | Check compliance, structure and the win strategy on an early draft | Early draft (often 20 to 40% complete) | Gaps in outline, compliance and solution |
| Red team | Score the proposal as an evaluator would and improve it | Near-final draft (often 80 to 90% complete) | A predicted score with strengths, weaknesses and fixes |
| Green team | Review and approve pricing | Before price is final | An approved price consistent with the solution |
| Gold team | Confirm red and green team changes are made and the proposal is ready | One to two days before submission | Final approval to submit |
| White hat | Capture lessons learned | After submission or debriefing | Notes to improve the next bid |
Purposes are from Shipley. The completion percentages and gold team timing are practitioner guidance from GovEagle, not a formal standard. "White glove" is also used for a final production check of formatting and files; it is common usage rather than a Shipley term.
Each review needs time after it for the team to make the fixes. Schedule the recovery time, not just the meeting.
Pink Team: Fix The Structure Early
Pink team looks at an early draft, when it is still cheap to change direction. Reviewers are not editing sentences. They are asking whether the proposal is built right:
- Does the outline follow Section L, in the order and with the headings the government asked for?
- Is every requirement in the compliance matrix assigned to a section?
- Do the win themes from capture appear where evaluators will look for them?
- Is the solution actually defined, or are sections still placeholders?
- Are page budgets realistic for each section?
Practitioners advise against line edits at pink team. Comments on wording are wasted on text that will change (GovEagle).
Red Team: Score It Like An Evaluator
Red team is the most important review. Reviewers read the near-final proposal "cold", as the evaluators will, and score it against the Section M factors. They should use the government's own language:
| Finding | What it means |
|---|---|
| Strength | Something that has merit or exceeds requirements in a way that benefits the government |
| Weakness | A flaw that increases the risk of unsuccessful performance |
| Significant weakness | A flaw that appreciably increases that risk |
| Deficiency | A material failure to meet a requirement |
Definitions follow the DoD Source Selection Procedures (2016). Use the rating scale in your solicitation when it gives one.
Lohfeld Consulting recommends about 25 to 30 pages per reviewer per day, at least two reviewers per evaluation factor, and the same reviewers across reviews so they can see whether earlier findings were fixed (Washington Technology). When time is short, red team is the review to protect.
Gold Team: Ready To Submit?
Gold team is a readiness check, not another round of writing. It confirms that red and green team findings were closed, that price and technical tell the same story, and that the proposal meets every submission rule: page limits, fonts, file names, forms and amendment acknowledgments. New strategy at gold team usually creates new errors.
How To Write Review Comments That Help
A review is only as useful as its comments. Here is the same comment written two ways. The example is fictional.
This section is weak and needs more detail.
The writer cannot tell what is wrong, where, how much it matters or how to fix it.
Section 2.3, page 8, Factor 1 (Technical): The transition plan promises "no disruption" but gives no staffing or timeline proof. An evaluator would likely record a weakness. Fix: add the 30-day transition schedule and name the transition lead with relevant experience.
It names the location, links to the Section M factor, predicts the rating effect and gives a specific fix the writer can act on.
Rank fixes by points at stake: compliance failures and deficiencies first, then weaknesses on the most important factors, then strengths that need proof to count, then editorial issues.

Free Template
Start Every Review With A Compliance Matrix
Reviewers work faster with a matrix that shows every requirement and where it is answered. Our free Excel template includes a coverage summary and a filled example.
Get The Free Template →Color Team Reviews For Small Teams
Small businesses rarely have spare people for six reviews. You do not need all of them. A practical minimum:
| If you have | Keep | How |
|---|---|---|
| Very little time | Red team | One outside reader scores the draft against Section M, even for a few hours |
| A normal schedule | Pink, red and gold | Pink on the outline and first draft, red on the near-final draft, gold as a checklist |
| No independent reviewers | A fresh reader for red team | Use a partner, advisor or paid reviewer who has not seen the drafts |
The rule that matters most: the people who wrote a section should not be the only ones who review it. Writers read what they meant to say, not what is on the page.
Common Mistakes
- Holding red team on a draft that is not finished enough to score
- Reviewers editing sentences at pink team
- Reviewing without the RFP and compliance matrix in hand
- Comments with no location, factor or fix
- No time scheduled to make the fixes
- Changing reviewers between pink and red
- New strategy at gold team
- Writers reviewing their own sections
Color Team Review Checklist
Use this to plan and run each review. Tick items off as you go, or copy the list into your proposal schedule.
Color Team Review Checklist
Tip: copy this into your proposal schedule and assign an owner to each review.
Key Takeaways
- Each color team has one job. Agree what each means before you schedule it.
- Pink fixes structure early; red scores like an evaluator; gold confirms readiness.
- Reviewers should not be the writers, and every comment needs a location, factor and fix.
- If you can only do one review, protect red team.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a red team proposal review?
A red team review is a mock evaluation of a near-final proposal. Reviewers who did not write it read it cold and score it against the solicitation's evaluation criteria (Section M), recording strengths, weaknesses and deficiencies with specific fixes.
What is a pink team review?
A pink team review checks an early draft for compliance, structure and win strategy. It confirms the outline follows Section L, every requirement has a home and the solution is defined. Reviewers avoid line edits because the text will change.
What is a gold team review?
A gold team review is a final readiness check one or two days before submission. It confirms earlier findings were fixed, price matches the technical approach and every submission rule is met. It is not a time for new strategy.
What is the Shipley proposal method?
Shipley Associates is a proposal consulting and training firm whose process includes gated capture and proposal phases and the color team reviews many contractors use. Its public definitions give each color team one purpose, such as pink for compliance and red for predicting the score.
How many reviewers does a red team need?
Lohfeld Consulting suggests at least two reviewers per evaluation factor and about 25 to 30 pages per reviewer per day. Small teams can scale this down, but at least one independent reader per volume is worth the effort.
Can a small business skip color team reviews?
You can skip some, but not all. If time is short, keep a red team review by someone who did not write the proposal. It is the review most likely to catch what costs points.
Want An Independent Red Team?
Our Proposal Review is one color team review (pink, red or gold) by people who did not write your draft. We check compliance against Sections L and M, score it the way an evaluator would and rank the fixes by the points at stake.
Sources
- Shipley Associates: Color team reviews
- GovEagle: Pink, red and gold team reviews playbook
- Washington Technology (Lohfeld): How to review your proposal to move beyond acceptable
- DoD Source Selection Procedures (2016)
Related Guides
Talk To Us About Your Next Bid
Book a free call at a time that suits you. We will come back with a clear view of where to start.